TL;DR
- We tested five proxy providers across seven setups, with 50 requests to Amazon product pages per setup.
- Scrapingdog’s rotating proxy returned all 50 pages and averaged 6.29 seconds. Pricing starts at $0.0002 per successfully scraped page and can drop below $0.00002 at higher volumes.
- Bright Data’s datacenter proxies were the fastest setup to return all 50 pages, averaging 2.34 seconds. Its residential proxies returned 49 of 50 pages and averaged 19.60 seconds.
- Oxylabs, Decodo, and Infatica had success rates of 6% to 16% in our test. Try your own Amazon product URLs before committing to a plan.
Let’s be honest, scraping Amazon is no longer an easy task. With Amazon’s constantly evolving anti-bot measures, you need reliable, high-quality proxies to extract data without getting blocked.
In this article, we’ll put 5 of the best proxy providers to the test and compare their performance, success rates, and pricing. By the end, you’ll have a clear idea of which proxy provider best fits your scraping needs and budget.
Criteria
Scalability- How many Amazon product and search pages can be scraped in a particular time frame.
Pricing- Comparison based on per-page scraping.
Support- How good is the support.
Developer-friendly- How well written the documentation is.
Success Rate
1import os2import re3import time4import random5import html as htmllib6import requests7import urllib38 9urllib3.disable_warnings(urllib3.exceptions.InsecureRequestWarning)10 11amazon_product_urls = [12 "https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09B8V1LZ3",13 "https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0BDHWDR12",14 "https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08XVYZ1Y5",15 "https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00FLYWNYQ",16 "https://www.amazon.com/dp/0735211299",17 "https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09HM94VDS",18 "https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09XS7JWHH",19 "https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08KTZ8249",20 "https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08C1W5N87",21]22 23proxy_url = 'proxy_url'24proxies = {"http": proxy_url, "https": proxy_url}25 26 27 28DEBUG = True29if DEBUG:30 os.makedirs("debug", exist_ok=True)31 32 33def is_legit(html: str) -> bool:34 # Python equivalent of the JS check: bad page = neither marker present35 return ('id="productTitle"' in html) or ('window.amznMusic' in html)36 37 38total_requests = 5039success = blocked = failed = completed = 040total_time = 0.041 42for i in range(total_requests):43 url = random.choice(amazon_product_urls)44 try:45 start = time.time()46 r = requests.get(url, proxies=proxies, verify=False, timeout=60)47 elapsed = time.time() - start48 completed += 149 total_time += elapsed50 51 html = r.text52 53 if r.status_code != 200:54 failed += 155 label = f"HTTP_{r.status_code}"56 elif is_legit(html):57 success += 158 label = "OK"59 else:60 blocked += 161 label = "BLOCKED"62 63 if DEBUG and label == "BLOCKED":64 with open(f"debug/{i+1:03d}_{label}.html", "w", encoding="utf-8") as f:65 f.write(html)66 67 print(f"Request {i+1} {url} {elapsed:.2f}s status={r.status_code} len={len(html)} -> {label}")68 except Exception as e:69 failed += 170 print(f"Request {i+1} {url} failed: {e}")71 72avg = total_time / completed if completed else 073print(f"\nTotal Requests: {total_requests}")74print(f"Successful: {success} | Soft-blocked: {blocked} | Failed: {failed}")75print(f"Success Rate: {success / total_requests * 100:.2f}%")76print(f"Average Time per Completed Request: {avg:.2f}s")We will use this Python code to test each proxy provider.
ScrapingdogÂ
Scrapingdog offers a rotating proxy, which is a mixture of datacenter proxy and residential proxy.
Scrapingdog follows a credit-based pricing model, meaning you are charged only when a page is successfully scraped. You don’t have to worry about the page size, as it doesn’t affect the cost.
They offer 24*7 chat support to paid subscribers.
Start scraping Amazon with Scrapingdog for as little as $0.0002 per page. As your scraping volume increases, the cost can drop to less than $0.00002 per page.
Scrapingdog Proxy Testing on AmazonÂ
We got a 100% success rate with a 6.29 second average response time with Scrapingdog Proxies.
The success rate and average response time metrics of Scrapingdog are public. You can track that here.
Brightdata
Brightdata offers all kinds of proxies like residential, datacenter, ISP and mobile.
Their residential proxy pricing starts at $3.50 per GB, with a minimum monthly commitment of $499, while datacenter proxies start at $1.20 per IP.
Support is available 24*7 and I would say they offer the best support in the industry. The support team is trained enough to answer your technical questions.
Brightdata Residential Proxy Testing on AmazonÂ
We got a 98% success rate with Brightdata Residential Proxies, with an average response time of 19.60 seconds.
An average response time of 19.60 seconds is a bit on the higher side, especially considering their premium pricing.
Brightdata Datacenter Proxy Testing on AmazonÂ
With Brightdata datacenter proxies, you got a 100% success rate with an average response time of 2.34 seconds.
OxylabsÂ
Oxylabs is a direct competitor of Brightdata. They too offer similar proxies with a slightly smaller pool than Brightdata.
Their support is horrible and does not respond for 2 3 days. You have to send them an alert email again to get a response.
The website is too noisy, and a beginner won’t be able to figure it out easily.
Documentation is well written. Developers can easily integrate their proxies.
Oxylabs Residential Proxy Testing on AmazonÂ
6% success rate with Oxylabs residential proxies.
Oxylabs Datacenter Proxy Testing on AmazonÂ
With Oxylabs datacenter proxies, we got a success rate of just 16%.
DecodoÂ
Decodo is from the same clan as Source.ai. So, they might offer the same pool as you get from Oxylabs. But it is worth testing them too.
Their support is decent, but getting through to a human agent can be a challenge. You’ll need a bit of luck to get past their AI chatbot first.
Documentation is clear, concise, and easy to integrate.
Before buying any plan, I recommend reading their Fair Usage Policy (FUP) carefully. For example, their ISP proxies are advertised with unlimited bandwidth, but the FUP limits traffic to just 25GB per IP. That’s quite disappointing, especially when you’re paying for unlimited bandwidth.
Decodo Datacenter Proxy Testing on AmazonÂ
We got a 10% success rate with Decodo.
Average response time was 1.90 seconds.
InfaticaÂ
Infatica is another popular proxy provider in the market. Their proxy pool is quite big and competes directly with companies like Brightdata.
They have a pool of 40M+ Residential proxies. But along with Residential and ISP, they also offer IPv6 premium residential proxies.
Their customer support is excellent. The team responds quickly and resolves issues without unnecessary delays.
Documentation is clear, and developers will find their proxies easy to use.
Infatica Datacenter Proxy Testing on AmazonÂ
The success rate was around 6%.
Average response time was 2.89 seconds.
VerdictÂ
We ran the same 50-request test against Amazon product pages for every provider. Only three setups came out usable.
| Provider | Success rate | Avg. response time |
|---|---|---|
| Scrapingdog (rotating) | 100% | 6.29s |
| Bright Data Datacenter | 100% | 2.34s |
| Bright Data Residential | 98% | 19.60s |
| Oxylabs Datacenter | 16% | Not recorded |
| Decodo Datacenter | 10% | 1.90s |
| Oxylabs Residential | 6% | Not recorded |
| Infatica | 6% | 2.89s |
Scrapingdog was the most practical option. It had a 100% success rate with a 6.29s average response time. You pay only for pages that are scraped successfully, regardless of page size, at roughly $0.0002 per page, falling below $0.00002 at volume. It also publishes its success rate and response time publicly.
Bright Data performed well, but the setup matters. Its datacenter proxies were the fastest reliable option at 100% and 2.34s. The residential pool reached 98% but took 19.60s on average, which is slow at a $499 monthly minimum and $3.50 per GB. It also has the best support in the group.
Oxylabs, Decodo and Infatica were not usable for Amazon in our test. Success rates ranged from 6% to 16%. Decodo and Infatica’s response times of 1.90s and 2.89s mean little when 90%+ of requests are blocked. Oxylabs also has slow support, and Decodo’s fair usage policy caps its “unlimited” ISP proxies at 25GB per IP.
ConclusionÂ
On Amazon, a proxy provider is only as good as its ability to avoid blocks. The speed numbers show a fast proxy that gets blocked is worse than a slower one that returns the page.
Best all-round pick: Scrapingdog gives you reliable results and per-page pricing, so you don’t pay for failed requests or have to estimate bandwidth.
Best for raw speed with a bigger budget: Bright Data datacenter proxies, if you are fine managing proxy infrastructure yourself.
Skip for Amazon: Oxylabs, Decodo and Infatica, based on what we saw. Results can change with Amazon’s defenses, so re-test with your own URLs before committing.